A large electronics company in the Asia-Pacific region chose Thailand as the home for a new factory expected to save about $20 million in operating costs each year, in a ‘China plus One’ strategy project led by Miebach in collaboration with JLL.
The electronics company signed a contract for a factory built to its specifications in the Bangkok area after narrowing a list of eleven countries to one. The move is meant to protect the business from the kind of shutdowns that hit its Chinese plants during the Covid-19 pandemic.
For decades, many manufacturers concentrated production in China, attracted by a skilled workforce and low costs. With a ‘China plus one’ strategy, a company keeps some operations in China, but adds a second production location in another country, often also in Asia. The aim is to avoid depending on a single location, so that a lockdown, trade dispute, or other disruption in one country does not halt business operations.
Setting the goal
The project began by agreeing on why the company wanted to move and what it needed from a new site. Lockdowns had repeatedly shut down its two factories in China and interrupted deliveries to key customers.
To avoid a repeat, the company decided to move all of its Asia-Pacific business outside China into one new factory, set to open two years after the project began. The site had to stay in the region to remain close to customers and keep labor costs low.
Agreeing on criteria
With 11 countries under consideration, the company and its advisers – Miebach(global supply chain consultancy) and JLL (a real estate expert) – first agreed on how to compare them. They set five main criteria, broken into 12 sub-criteria and more than 60 individual measures, and gave each a weight reflecting its importance. The workforce counted most at 35%. The regulatory and economic environment and the effect on the end-to-end supply chain each carried 20%, the quality of the location 15%, and the market and competitors 10%.
Each country received a score from one to 10, which also exposed specific risks, such as high geopolitical uncertainty in Taiwan. Taiwan, Laos, Cambodia, South Korea, and Japan were dropped, leaving Malaysia, Thailand, and Vietnam with the highest rankings.
Examining sites and costs
The team then took a closer look at six countries. Based on its real estate insights, JLL proposed available plots of land, based on an assessment of factors including industrial clusters, distances to ports and airports, proximity to customers and competitors, exposure to floods and earthquakes, the local workforce, government incentives, and access to renewable energy.
Miebach complemented that analysis with the operating costs for each location, including customs, transportation, labor, and facilities. India and Indonesia were dismissed for offering comparatively low savings and rankings. The Philippines showed high potential savings but was removed because of high environmental risks, long delivery times to customers, and little chance of sourcing raw materials locally.
Visiting the finalists
The last step was a two-week tour of the most promising regions in Thailand, Malaysia, and Vietnam. The project team viewed available plots and met local authorities, recruitment agencies, legal advisers, logistics experts, and other companies already operating there, to confirm the findings of the analysis and benchmarking phase.
Decision and expected benefits
Thailand offered the best balance between cost savings and fit with the company’s needs, and the contract for the Bangkok-area factory followed. In parallel, a JLL team began negotiating a tax incentive package with the Thai Board of Investment.
Once the factory is running, the electronics manufacturer expects annual savings along with $40 million in incentives on duties and corporate income tax, plus greater resilience and room for business growth.